[Fiware-security] FI-WARE Security - Outcomes of today's audio with CA regarding Security AT contrib to D2.3 (some work needed)

[BISSON Pascal]

Dear Alexandre,

In view of what you did already it should be fine from your side since compliant with ToC suggested and agreed.

Will let you know in case Juanjo's would need more.

Regards,
Pascal


-----Message d'origine-----
De : Alexandre Boeglin [mailto:alexandre.boeglin at inria.fr] 
Envoyé : lundi 5 mars 2012 17:28
À : BISSON Pascal
Cc : Seidl, Robert (NSN - DE/Munich); gabor.marton at nsn.com; norbert.goetze at nsn.com; slim.trabelsi at sap.com; francesco.di.cerbo at sap.com; GASPARD Lucie; osb at zurich.ibm.com; anj at zurich.ibm.com; antonio.garcia at atosorigin.com; Antonio Garcia Vazquez; LELEU Philippe; Wolfgang.Steigerwald at telekom.de; GIDOIN Daniel; Pedro Soria Rodriguez; fiware-security at lists.fi-ware.eu
Objet : Re: FI-WARE Security - Outcomes of today's audio with CA regarding Security AT contrib to D2.3 (some work needed)

Hello Pascal, everybody,

I have to say I don't exactly understand what we are asked to do here.

The original comment from Juanjo was quite generic ("adaption to
published guidelines"), and on February 21, our document already
contained the "Overview", "Basic Concepts" and "Main Interactions"
sections.

Daniel later asked us to add a "Basic Design Principles" section, which
was also done…

So, could you please elaborate on what we have to do to get the document
accepted ?


Thanks in advance.

Best regards,
Alexandre

Le lundi 05 mars 2012 à 15:11, BISSON Pascal a écrit:
> Dear Task leads/GE owners,
> 
> This just to let you know that this morning I had an audio conference with Juanjo were discussed the readiness of our GEs description for publication in the context of D2.3 and according to latest version available on FI-WARE Private wiki (https://forge.fi-ware.eu/plugins/mediawiki/wiki/fi-ware-private/index.php/FiwareDeliverableD2.3) aka the place where we are supposed to upload our GE description from our FI-WARE Security Private Wiki.
> 
> Here are what we discussed and agreed:
> 
>  *   We will proceed with publishing the contents linked to the Security Monitoring GE because despite some additional comments may come after a second review, it's worth publishing the current contents and we can deal with new comments by end of March (but without the pressure of delivery dates)
>  *   We will proceed with publishing the contents linked to the Identity Management GE provided that the owner commits to translate the figures to FMC format by end of this week.   As with the previous case, despite some additional comments may come after a second review, it's worth publishing the current contents and we can deal with new comments by end of March (but without the pressure of delivery dates)
>  *   We will publish the Privacy GE
>  *   We won't publish the rest pending on response regarding how the comments initially provided by Juanjo were addressed (please refer here to email I forwarded you from Juanjo - 21 février 2012 05:07 - on the topic ).   Apparently, comments were not addressed for some of the GEs, if not all, and even the history of the Wiki pages reflect that. In order not to delay any longer the publishing of our Security Chapter contrib. to D2.3 I will ask:
> o    Antonio as to check and address Juanjo's comments on Context-based security and compliance comments this  no later than by tomorrow EOB,
> o    Same for Slim or Francesco regarding Data Handling GE although after a quick scan I noticed they had already implemented a number of Juanjo's comments.
> o    Slim/Francesco, Alexandre, Philippe/Lucie to do the same for what concerns Optional Security GEs
> 
> Please Antonio, Slim/Francesco, Alexandre, Philippe/Lucie please acknowledge receipt of this email and confirm you would be addressing comments according the set deadline (i.e. by tomorrow EOB at the latest - hope earlier - let me know once done) to close our work on D2.3 and have our specifications be published also redirect our effort on our Security contrib. to D2.4.
> 
> Hearing from you,
> 
> Best Regards,
> 
> Pascal
> 
> PS: Don't forget to stick to suggested table of content if not done already and follow instructions provided at https://forge.fi-ware.eu/plugins/mediawiki/wiki/fi-ware-private/index.php/Instructions_on_how_to_develop_FI-WARE_Chapter_Architecture_Descriptions
> PS2: As announced will call for an audio conference tomorrow. Will provide you with details in a separate email.

-- 
Alexandre Boeglin
Équipe-Projet Madynes
INRIA